A BMW 328xi that is still in excellent driving condition. Wheels were replaced 1.5 years ago, and brakes were replaced 2 years ago, and other facets of car have been regularly maintained (i.e. regular oil changes + other fixes from maintenance checks).
The car hit a deer in 2011, causing cosmetic damage to the bumper, and the bumper ended up getting replaced. Over the last few years, the new bumper's paint has started to chip away, as shown in some of the pictures below. The paint on the car is otherwise in pristine condition and still looks very nice, as you will see from the photos. I'm factoring in the fact that you'll likely want to get the bumper touched up into the asking price -- taking about $500 off what I think it'd be worth if the bumper paint wasn't blemished.
The interior is also still in great condition and has been regularly treated/maintained over the years.