Don't be fooled by the Autocheck - there wasn't an accident. The only damage was to the licence plate when the bracket broke off..I contacted Autocheck in hope that they will actually do some research. The police dropped the charges and no one was ever charge with the mishap...even though it was leaving the an accident scene but that's how minor it really was.
I've lowered the reserve price and dropped the buy it now price well under private seller KBB.